Site Meter Battlestar Galactica » Blog Archive » Commentary: Bastille Day

Commentary: Bastille Day

by Margie

Today is Bastille Day in France and a good opportunity to comment on “Bastille Day,” the famous prison riot episode from Battlestar Galactica’s first season. Looking back, this was one of the first episodes where the threat from within the fleet loomed as large as the threat of the Cylons, and where viewers started to understand that the challenge of building a stable society after the Cylon attacks was even more daunting than the challenge of simply surviving day to day.

The first episode of the series, “33″ focused on the survival aspect. The second episode, “Water,” introduced viewers to the idea of an internal threat. “Bastille Day” cemented the concept that death and destruction could come from within the fleet as easily as from the Cylons, as there is an intrinsic violence in human nature that even a nuclear holocaust cannot purge.

Battlestar Galactica has always been dark and violent, but “Bastille Day” took the violence to an intimate and personal level that was new to the series. It also continued the theme of sexual violence that was present from the first scene of the series, when a Number Six model Cylon appears in the Armistice Station and sexually assaults the officer waiting there while murmuring “It has begun.” It makes sense that this would be the point in the plot where threats become personal, because a series that starts with the deaths of millions of people naturally makes its audience numb to wide-scale violence. Like Jericho, over time the audience comes to accept that those in the outside world are most likely dead or dying and comes to care more about the safety of the main characters of the show.

The plot of “Bastille Day” surrounds one of the ongoing conflicts of Battlestar Galactica, the constant struggle to do what is right while also doing what is needed to survive. The fleet desperately needs water, but extracting it from the only water source available at the time is a labor intensive process. A delegation led by Lee “Apollo” Adama is sent to a prison ship traveling with the fleet in the hopes of convincing them to provide the labor, but the prisoners have other goals in mind. Their selfishness leads to violence that threatens the fleet visitors, and also threatens the very delicate political stability that is holding the new society together.

One of the most disturbing subplots involves the attempted rape of Cally, and commentary by producers David Eick and Ronald Moore reveals that originally she was supposed to be raped and murdered in this episode. In the final version of the script she fights back, bites the prisoner’s ear off, and avoids actual forced penetration by her attacker … but she is shot and wounded in the fight. This is another theme of Battlestar Galactica, this type of “consolation violence.” Being sexually assaulted and shot would be devastating under other circumstances, but on BSG it is better than the alternative. Throughout the series, the characters are written as being grateful for having lived through whatever trauma may befall them. That alone takes its toll, the way the characters on Battlestar Galactica do not have time to absorb whatever traumas occur because they are too busy trying to survive.

When compared to the episodes and characters of BSG’s third season, it is clear how this push to survive is taking its psychological toll on the characters. Perhaps the most striking contrast is the President Roslin of “Bastille Day,” who refuses to force the prisoners to work as slave labor even though the very survival of the fleet depends on it. Her attitude in this episode is striking when compared to the President Roslin of Season Three’s “Dirty Hands,” who is willing to force innocent children to work long hours doing manual labor and is not concerned about condemning them to a life void of choice and personal freedom. It has been a long three years for Roslin, three years of personal loss and horrible choices. Watching “Bastille Day” after Season Three really shows how the stress of these seasons has taken its toll on the characters… and how much of humanity has been lost along the way.

“Bastille Day” also lays the foundation for many of the plot points that still are being played out in Battlestar Galactica: who are the Cylons within the fleet, the importance of presidential politics, the animosity between Adama, Roslin, and Baltar, the way violence erodes psychological stability, and a myriad of other themes that have yet to be resolved even after all this time.

, , , , , , , , , , , , ,


One Response to “Commentary: Bastille Day”

  1. Bionic Woman » Blog Archive » Bionic Blackwater & Other Bionic Woman Newslinks for Oct. 19, 2007 Says:

    [...] people think of David Eick’s other show, Battlestar Galactica, when they talk about timely topics on television. But Paul Krugman of the New York Times thinks [...]

Leave a Reply


About Battlestar Galactica

If you enjoy talking and thinking about the people, places, philosophies, and personalities over on New Caprica then this is the site for you. Whether you have been watching BSG from the beginning or just ordered the pilot from Netflix last week, watchingbsg.com is a great place to visit.

Battlestar Galactica Author(s)
    » Margie

TV Channel Posts

  • Innnteresting!
    So, which one of the houseguests will figure it out first? They're supposed o be fans of the game, right? They never, ever, EVER show pictures on the memory wall without an ulterior motive... No [...]
  • Happy Live Show Day!
    Good Morning, Hamster Lovers! It's our first live show day! I'm so EXCITED! AGP has really stepped it up with this cast, and the two shows so far - I'm extremely pleased so far, and can only hope the [...]
  • Paul Rauch Joining Y&R
    According to TV Guide Paul Rauch is joining The Young & the Restless as a Creative Consultant. In the past Rauch has work on Guiding Light, Santa Barbara, and One Life to Live. [...]
  • Hello Out There????
    It's been a while! This site has been down for a few weeks...451's servers have been having problems, but the upside to that is that they spent a bunch of money on new techie stuff, so things should [...]
  • Rescue Me Mini-Episode, News, Etc.
    And we finally got a sentimental, or at least quasi-sentimental Rescue Me minisode last night. As the firehouse used its final moments to banter about surefire hall of famers and the likelihood they [...]
  • We're Back with 'Heroes' News!
    I have to apologize for my absence as well as the downtime on the site. I'm told that the server issues are fixed and after some brief downtime this week, we should be back for good...and better than [...]
  • The View July 16th
    Today's recap will not be up anytime soon. (I have gotten more realistic. I used to say it would be up later, but really, who am I kidding?). On today's show: Seth Green will be on to promote [...]
  • TV on DVD Review of the Week: Hello Kitty Tells Fairy Tales
    The DVD Hello Kitty Tells Fairy Tales contains episodes from the animated television series called Hello Kitty's Furry Tale Theatre, which originally aired on the Family Channel back in 1986. [...]
  • MTV’s Survivor Style Challenge
    Last week I rambled on about how MTV had not done a challenge since the Gauntlet 3. Well I can stop ranting. MTV is bringing us an all new challenge in the fall. There was a promo the other night [...]
  • Season 1 Flashback: Running to Stand Still
    Good morning, everyone. Ready to catch up on season 1 some more? This time, we’re gonna talk about the episode "Running to Stand Still". When we left The Solis house last time, Carlos’ mom [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Rumer Willis needs a bra, badly!
    While I have nothing against those who feel more comfortable without a bra, I certainly think Rumer Willis case is different. Attending the Power of Paws launch party yesterday, Rumer shows [...]
  • The Birth of Religion - Part 7
    by Seeker SO just what is it that started us on the spiritual path as a race? Graham Hancock started as an investigative journalist and has a string of books behind him that have a common thread [...]
  • Innnteresting!
    So, which one of the houseguests will figure it out first? They're supposed o be fans of the game, right? They never, ever, EVER show pictures on the memory wall without an ulterior motive... No [...]
  • Grass dancing showcases native culture, tradition
    Many students at Central Michigan University take pride in calling themselves "Chippewas." But for Makwa Stevens, a direct descendent of the Chippewa/Ojibwe Indian tribe, the word bears greater [...]
  • Suri at Union Station
      This little number surprised me as I never thought Katie would put her daughter in an outfit she's already worn. BUT I LOVE this Pucci dress. Isn't it cute on her? Oh and for those of you that [...]
  • Sign the Petition Against Madatory Green Lightbulbs
    This post is aimed more for American readers. My apologies to non-American readers. You can go look at Brad Pitt photos here. Anyway, American Migraineurs... A petition to Congress has been [...]
  • Enemas and Enemies
    And, naturally, all hell breaks loose - and not between who you think. We didn't see the actual fight, but it's been nothing but aftermath ever since. April started talking behind Keesha's back and [...]
  • Hello Out There????
    It's been a while! This site has been down for a few weeks...451's servers have been having problems, but the upside to that is that they spent a bunch of money on new techie stuff, so things should [...]
  • If I had a Million Dollars I'd buy a shit-ton of Coke
    Barenaked Ladies singer, Steven J. Page, was arrested in central New York on Friday and was charged with fourth degree criminal possession of a controlled substance, that substance being tasty, tasty [...]
  • Financial support helps reinstate men’s swimming
    Team to compete fully in 2008-09 Arizona State University Vice President for Athletics Lisa Love announced July 15, that the athletic department is fully reinstating the sport of varsity men’s [...]